top of page

Deaf, Blind and Disabled Travellers at International Airports: True Stories, Real Numbers and How to Stay Safe

5 days ago
12 min read


True stories, real percentages, banned items and fines, and safety steps for Deaf, blind and disabled travellers at international airports. Every number has a source.

Three Deaf friends, one flight, nine years


On May 30, 2017, Khalil Haj and two Deaf friends were told to leave an AirAsia flight to Cebu at Puerto Princesa airport in the Philippines. The three were on their way to a Filipino Sign Language conference. The reason given: they had no hearing companion.


The airline's own rules said the opposite. Its ground manual called a Deaf passenger "self-reliant" and free to refuse an escort. A companion was needed only for groups of four or more Deaf passengers, and Haj's group was three.


Haj was offered ₱500,000 and free flights to settle. His two friends took the offer, and he said no. Student interns from a university legal aid clinic helped him keep going.


In a ruling reported in early November 2026, a Philippine court convicted the former senior cabin crew member of discrimination and set the fine at ₱50,000. The judge saw no real safety issue. The court could not conclude she acted from malice, but found she refused to carry him on purpose because of his disability.


This is a true story. It took nine years. This blog explains how common these problems are, what the real numbers say, what you cannot bring through an airport, and how Deaf, blind and disabled travellers can protect themselves.



How many people are we talking about?


One in six people in the world lives with a significant disability. Every international airport serves these travellers every day.


Group

World estimate

Source

People with a significant disability

1.3 billion, about 16% of the world

Deaf people

About 70 million, with more than 200 sign languages

People with vision impairment, including blindness

At least 2.2 billion


Developing countries are home to more than 80% of Deaf people. Vision loss is most common after age 50, so many blind travellers are also elderly travellers.


The percentages: what is measured and what is not


No one has a world percentage for airport discrimination against Deaf, blind or disabled travellers. No trustworthy ranking of countries exists. Only a few countries count these problems, and each one counts something different.


Where

What was counted

Result

Source

Canada, 2025

Travellers with disabilities who met a barrier at an airport, train station, bus or ferry terminal

40%

Canada, 2025

Of those who met a barrier, the share with a communication barrier

37%

Canada, 2021

People with disabilities who met a barrier on federally regulated transportation

63% overall; 78% with hearing difficulties; 72% with seeing difficulties

Europe, 2025

Survey respondents who said air travel is not equally accessible

67%

United Kingdom, 2024/25

Airports rated "needs improvement" for assistance

3 of 28

United Kingdom, 2025/26

Airports rated "needs improvement" for assistance

0 of 28

United States, 2023

Disability complaints received by airlines

49,082 complaints



How to read these numbers honestly

  • In Canada, Deaf and hard of hearing people reported the most transportation barriers of any group.

  • Unclear instructions from customer service, gate or security staff topped the list of communication barriers in Canada.

  • Only 251 people answered the Europe survey, and about 5% of them had a hearing disability, so it says little about Deaf travellers alone. (EDF methodology)

  • A barrier is not always discrimination. A complaint is not proof that staff lied.

  • Countries that publish numbers are not the worst countries. They are the ones that count. For most of Asia, Africa, the Middle East and Latin America, no comparable airport numbers exist.


What nobody has counted: how many airport workers, guards, flight attendants or pilots falsely blame passengers, and how many innocent Deaf, blind or elderly travellers are jailed. Anyone who gives you a percentage for that is guessing.


The barriers each group faces


The danger is usually the same: staff read a disability as bad behaviour.


Traveller

Common barrier

How it gets twisted

Deaf and hard of hearing

Spoken instructions, gate changes and emergency alerts by sound only; no interpreter

"Ignoring orders", "refusing to cooperate", even "drunk"

Blind and low vision

Cannot see a bag search, a form, or who is speaking

Asked to sign papers they cannot read

Wheelchair and mobility aid users

Separated from their chair; left waiting on the aircraft; unsafe lifting

Told it was their choice to travel alone

Brain injury, cognitive or hidden disabilities

Fast questions, noise, no extra time

Slow answers read as lying

Elderly travellers

Hearing, vision and memory changes together

Confusion read as trouble-making


True stories, with the real amounts


These five cases come from court records, government orders or news reports. Only one involves a traveller put in jail.


Case

What happened

Result

Type

Khalil Haj, Philippines, 2017 to 2026

Three Deaf passengers removed from a flight

₱50,000 fine on the former crew member

Criminal conviction

Karen McGee, United States, 2022

A 71-year-old woman with hearing loss was arrested at the airport and jailed

US$92,500 paid by the county

Settlement

Bernice Kekona, United States, 2017

A 75-year-old disabled passenger fell down an airport escalator and later died

US$3.19 million

Jury verdict

Nathaniel Foster Jr., United States, 2019

A quadriplegic passenger suffered a severe brain injury while being taken off a plane

US$30 million

Settlement

American Airlines, United States, 2019 to 2023

Unsafe wheelchair help and damaged wheelchairs

US$50 million

Government penalty


The story closest to every Deaf traveller's fear


Karen McGee, 71, had a layover in Austin, Texas, on September 13, 2022. A gate change was announced, she did not hear it, and her flight left without her.


She asked staff for another flight. By her account, nobody wrote answers down or faced her so she could lipread, and staff labelled her drunk when she was not. Police gave her a trespass warning she could not hear.


Two nights in jail followed, and she left with a broken wrist. More than 20 times, she says, she told jail staff she could not hear or understand them. Travis County later settled her lawsuit for US$92,500.


Nobody planted anything. A missed announcement became "drunk", then "trespassing", then jail. That is how blame grows when no one stops to write a sentence on paper.



What the other cases teach


  • Kekona: Jurors put 90% of the responsibility on the airline, which had argued her family should not have let her travel alone. Travelling alone is a legal right. (KIRO 7)

  • Foster: Legal fees took roughly US$12 million of the settlement and other costs took US$3 million. (New Mobility, CBS News)

  • American Airlines: Half of the penalty, US$25 million, went to the US Treasury, and the other half was credited toward equipment, wheelchair tagging and compensation for affected passengers. (TravelPulse)

  • Haj: the fine was small. The point was the conviction. He turned down ten times that amount to get it.


Pros and cons of airport security for disabled travellers


The problem is not security. The problem is security that only works for people who can hear, see and answer fast.


Pros

Cons

Screening keeps dangerous items off aircraft

Spoken-only instructions cause misunderstandings

CCTV can prove what really happened

Footage can be erased if no one asks to keep it

Assistance services make independent travel possible

Assistance can be late, missing or unsafe

Written signs and screens help Deaf travellers

Gate changes and emergencies are often announced by sound only

Complaint systems and courts exist

Cases are slow and costly. Haj waited nine years

Some regulators now rate and fine airports and airlines

Most countries publish no numbers at all


How to protect yourself from manipulation, twisting and blame


Most airport workers are not trying to hurt anyone. Poor training causes most problems. But when something goes wrong, the story can change fast, and the traveller who cannot hear or see the conversation is the easiest one to blame.


Before you travel


  1. Tell the airline about your access needs when you book, and again 48 hours before the flight. Do it by email so you have proof.

  2. Save a communication card on your phone lock screen and carry a paper copy.

  3. Check whether your airports use the Hidden Disabilities Sunflower lanyard. The program now covers 340 airports in 70 countries. (SFO Airport)

  4. Turn on flight alerts by text or app, so a gate change reaches you without sound.

  5. Photograph your packed bags. Lock them. Never carry anything for another person.

  6. Save your embassy's phone number and email. Share your itinerary with someone at home.


When someone tries to twist the story


What they say or do

What protects you

"You ignored my instructions"

Show your card first. Ask for every instruction in writing. Keep the paper

"You need a hearing companion"

Ask to see the written policy. In the Haj case the airline's own manual said the opposite

"You are drunk" or "you are aggressive"

Stay still and calm. Write: "I am Deaf. I am not refusing. Please write." Ask for a supervisor

"Just sign here"

Do not sign anything you cannot read or do not understand

They search your bag where you cannot follow

Ask to be present. Blind travellers can ask staff to describe each step aloud

"Pay this fee now" with no receipt

Ask for an official receipt and a supervisor

The story changes later

The same day, write down the time, place, gate, names and badge numbers. Email it to yourself

"There is no video"

Ask in writing, quickly, for CCTV and incident reports to be kept


Three rules to remember


  • Paper beats memory. Written words cannot be twisted as easily as spoken ones.

  • Calm beats right. Never resist physically, even when you are right. Fight it later, on paper.

  • Witnesses help. Ask a nearby traveller for their name and email if they saw what happened.


Recording glasses, pens and cameras: are they allowed?


You can usually carry a recording device. Using it is a different question, and the answer changes by country and by area of the airport.


  • United States: Photos and video at TSA checkpoints are not banned, provided you do not get in the way of screening. Equipment monitors shielded from public view are off limits. Local or state laws may be stricter. (TSA)

  • Customs and immigration areas: many countries forbid recording there. Look for the signs.

  • Other countries: rules vary widely. In some places, filming security staff or secretly recording sound is a crime. A disability does not create an exception.


Safer than a hidden camera:


  1. Email the airport before you travel and ask where recording is allowed. Keep the reply.

  2. Record openly with your phone where it is allowed. Stop if an officer lawfully tells you to.

  3. If something happens, ask in writing for the airport's own CCTV to be kept.


A hidden recording made where it is illegal can turn you from the victim into the accused. Ask first.


What you cannot bring: food, beach sand, shells and more


The most common way an innocent traveller gets fined at an airport is a forgotten apple, a sandwich, or a small bottle of beach sand. Every country has its own list, and no single world list exists. These are confirmed examples.



Food, plants and animal products when you arrive


Country

What gets travellers fined

Fine or penalty

Source

Australia

Any undeclared food, plant or animal item

A$728 minimum; A$7,280 if the item was hidden. Visas can be cancelled

New Zealand

Undeclared food, plants, animal products, even by accident

NZ$400 instant fine, with no criminal conviction. Deliberate smuggling: up to NZ$100,000

United States

Undeclared meat, fruit, vegetables, plants, seeds, soil

Up to US$1,000 for a first offence

Canada

Undeclared food, plant and animal products

C$500, C$800 or C$1,300 per violation

Great Britain

Beef, lamb, goat and pork, and dairy products, from EU countries, including a ham or cheese sandwich

Items taken away; up to £5,000 in severe cases

Japan

Meat products, fruit and vegetables brought in illegally

Up to 3 years in prison or up to ¥3 million


Beach sand, shells, coral and stones when you leave


Place

What you cannot take

Fine or penalty

Source

Sardinia, Italy

Sand, shells and pebbles. Bags are checked at the airports

€500 to €3,000

Hawaii, United States

Sand, dead coral and coral rubble. Beach glass and shells are still allowed

Illegal under state law. News reports put fines at US$100,000 or more

Lalaria Beach, Skiathos, Greece

White pebbles

About US$468 to US$1,170

Maldives

Sand, shells and coral

Prohibited. No official fine amount confirmed

Travel guides only

Thailand

Coral

Prohibited. No official fine amount confirmed

Travel guides only


Other items that surprise travellers


  • Vapes in Singapore. A vape in your bag counts as possession even if you never leave the transit area at Changi Airport, and since May 1, 2026 the fine can reach S$10,000. Check the Health Sciences Authority before you fly. (Air Traveler Club)

  • Soil on shoes and wooden souvenirs. Australia, New Zealand, Canada and the United States ask about these too.

  • Medicines. Some common medicines are controlled in other countries. Carry them in the original box with your prescription.


The one rule that protects you: declare it


In Australia, New Zealand, the United States and Canada, the fine is for not declaring, not for having the item. If you declare a banned item, the officer usually just takes it away.


  • Eat or throw away all food before you leave the plane, including airline snacks.

  • If you are not sure, tick "yes" on the form.

  • Deaf travellers: officers often ask the food question fast and by voice. Ask for the question in writing, and point to your written declaration.

  • Blind travellers: ask someone to read every question on the arrival card or kiosk aloud before you answer.

  • Keep a photo of your declaration. It proves you told the truth.

  • Leave the sand and shells on the beach. Take photos instead.


If you are falsely accused or detained


Ask for four things, in this order: the reason, an interpreter or written communication, a lawyer, and your embassy.


  1. Ask why you are being held. Ask for it in writing.

  2. Ask for a qualified sign language interpreter, or for everything in writing.

  3. Ask for a lawyer before you answer questions or sign anything.

  4. Ask the authorities to contact your embassy. For Canadians, nobody is required to tell a Canadian office about the arrest unless the detained person asks.

  5. Ask for CCTV, bag records and incident reports to be kept.


Be realistic about your embassy. Canadian consular staff have no power to get you out of prison, and the local justice system applies to you. (Government of Canada)


The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities supports you here. Article 13 covers equal access to justice, including accommodations such as interpreters. Article 14 says disability must never be the reason for taking away a person's liberty. How strongly this is enforced depends on the country.


Can you sue for a million dollars?


Sometimes, but not automatically. Being innocent does not by itself mean anyone owes you money. A lawyer has to show who was responsible and what harm it caused.

The real cases show the range:


  • ₱50,000 fine (Haj, Philippines). He was not asking for money.

  • US$92,500 settlement (McGee, arrest and injury).

  • US$3.19 million jury verdict (Kekona, death after an assistance failure).

  • US$30 million settlement (Foster, catastrophic brain injury).


The largest amounts followed death or life-changing injury, not discrimination alone.

In Canada, the Canadian Transportation Agency's 2026 limit is C$24,147.66 for pain and suffering, and the same again where a barrier came from a wilful or reckless practice. For incidents during an international flight, the Montreal Convention narrows this to cases with physical injury. (Canadian Transportation Agency)


To keep your right to sue: see a lawyer in the country where it happened, quickly, because deadlines can be short. Keep boarding passes, receipts, medical records and every message. Do not sign a settlement without legal advice.


A communication card to save on your phone


I AM DEAF. I USE SIGN LANGUAGE AND WRITTEN ENGLISH
Please do not shout. Please write, or provide a qualified sign language interpreter.
I am not refusing to cooperate. I cannot hear you.
If I am accused or detained, I ask for an interpreter, a lawyer and contact with my embassy.
I will not sign anything I do not understand.

Blind travellers can change the first lines to: "I AM BLIND. Please tell me who you are and describe what you are doing with my belongings."


Where to report


Country

Who to contact

Canada

Canadian Transportation Agency, accessibility complaints. The provider gets 30 days to respond first

United States

Department of Transportation, Office of Aviation Consumer Protection

United Kingdom

Civil Aviation Authority

European Union

The National Enforcement Body in the country where it happened

Anywhere

The airline and airport in writing, your embassy, and the national Deaf or disability association


What airports and airlines must change


  • Every spoken announcement also shown on screens and sent by text.

  • A qualified interpreter, in person or by video, for any serious questioning.

  • Disability awareness training for security, customs, immigration, gate and cabin staff.

  • A rule that police are not called on a passenger until someone has tried writing to them.

  • CCTV kept automatically whenever a passenger is detained or removed.

  • Yearly public numbers on disability complaints, removals and detentions, so that every country can be measured.


Deafness is not a crime


Khalil Haj could have taken the money. He waited nine years so that a court would say it out loud: refusing a passenger because he is Deaf is against the law.


Deafness is not a crime. Blindness is not a crime. Disability is not suspicious behaviour. Needing more time is not refusing to cooperate.


Travel should bring freedom and good memories. Prepare, keep everything in writing, know your rights, and share this with someone who is about to fly.


Equal Rights. Equal Access. Equal Safety. Equal Justice.


Cherlan Design, Deaf Travel Awareness | www.cherlandesign.com



Editorial and legal notice

This article is for public education. It is not legal advice.


The cases involve different legal issues. A settlement is not an admission of wrongdoing. The McGee details come from her lawsuit and her lawyers. The Haj ruling can still be appealed. Government fines are not compensation paid to passengers.


Laws, fines and recording rules change and differ by country. Check official sources before you travel, and speak to a qualified lawyer about any real incident.

 
 
 

Comments


HOT RELEASES

bottom of page